There was a girl in grade school who stood out and not in the way you’d want to be remembered. Long, straggly, greasy hair that never saw a good trim – or even shampoo for that matter.
All of us girls used to roll our skirts at the waist to make them look shorter (the height of Catholic school rebellion). Mary tried too, bless her heart, but her roll was always uneven. One side up, one side down, like her skirt was constantly in a state of confusion. Some of the boys couldn’t resist yanking the high side down as they passed by her. Real cute, guys. Real cute.
And then there were the nuns – our teachers. Every so often they’d play the game of desk shuffle. Their goal? Break up the chatterboxes. Our goal? Pray we landed next to a friend and not someone who smelled like a science experiment gone wrong.
The kids who got shoved to the back of the room were awarded prime real estate and strutted like they’d just won the lottery. The poor souls moved to the front? Penance. Whatever they’d done in a prior life, they were going to have full nun-eye contact on them now. Fun and games were over.
Sadly, Mary had a body odor that made sitting next to her… let’s just say “memorable.” Boys behind her would slowly inch their desks back until the few inch gap became more like a moat. The nuns, of course, eventually noticed and shoved them right back up, snug as a sandwich. They weren’t happy until the front of the desk behind, clanked against the back of the chair attached to the desk in front of them.

Then came the day of desk shuffle when it was my turn to sit directly behind Mary. My mature, compassionate friends whispered, “Ewww, you have to sit behind Mary.” And like the mature, compassionate soul I wasn’t, I whispered back, “Ugh, I know.”
God, I hope she didn’t hear me.
Looking back, maybe the teacher thought I was a good fit. They thought I wouldn’t make a stink (no pun intended). I failed. Peer pressure won out.
I swear a part of the whole desk shuffle game was just so the teacher could watch our reaction. It was their own private reality show. I imagined them sitting at their desk with a stopwatch in hand. “Okay, let’s see how long it takes before these Chatty Cathys realize they’re in the wrong seat.”

Brainiac Jerry, a destined future GPS software engineer, figured it out before he even sat down. He must have sniffed it in the air. “This isn’t mine.” Stopwatch click: 2 seconds.
Nancy, on the other hand, was thrilled to discover a stash of gum inside her desk. Never mind that she hadn’t put it there – it was like Christmas morning. She just sat there – happily, inconspicuously, chewing away – completely oblivious that she was in someone else’s seat. Stopwatch click: Infinity.
Then there were the kids who strolled up and down the aisle, looking for the desk that had the identifying doodle of the heart with an arrow through it, enveloping their initials and the person they were destined to be together forever with.
And of course, the perfectly content ones – they would’ve stayed there forever, blissfully unaware, as if the nuns had gifted them a new identity. “Oh, this is my desk now? Great. I’ll just start fresh.”
The whole desk shuffle was less about breaking up chatterboxes and more about watching us squirm. They definitely got more entertainment out of it than we did.
After all, it certainly wasn’t going to eliminate note passing. As if distance could remedy that. Please. All it meant was more taps on shoulders, more sneaky hand-offs down the row, and more grubby little fingers on that precious triangular folded piece of paper.

And then – oh, the grand reveal! The receiver would cradle the note low in their lap, as if it was contraband. Slowly , carefully, they’d begin to unfold it, making sure not to rustle a single corner too loudly, which was an impossible task, given those nuns had hearing like owls in a monastery. The receiver’s eyes would dart around the room, scanning for danger like they were about to uncover the Holy Grail.

What did it say? Only something gloriously dumb. The kind of thing only a 5th grader would think was worth risking a trip to the principal’s office for:
“Do you like me? Circle yes or no,”
All that pageantry and effort for a message that could’ve been shouted across the room in two seconds flat.
Gym class had to be the worst for Mary. The dreaded moment of picking teams still makes me cringe. It was cruel then, and I hate it just as much today. Because we all know, picking teams means someone always has to be picked last. And that somebody was almost always Mary.
Watching her stand there, waiting, knowing what was coming, was painful. It’s not a good feeling being the last one chosen, and it’s a tradition that should’ve been retired decades ago. Seriously, stop doing that.
Picking teams was like watching a slow-motion train wreck. The gym teacher would nominate the captains, and for about 30 seconds, you’d swear that title gave some of them the illusion of Olympic greatness.
The captains then began taking turns calling out names. And then there was Mary. Always last. Always silent. Often, not even called by her name. Just left to shuffle over to the team that didn’t want her. Public humiliation at its finest.

Fast forward 55 years. Out of nowhere, Mary popped into my head. I typed her name into Facebook. I clicked on the first one that popped up. Because she didn’t have a profile picture (go figure), I scrolled through hundreds of her pictures.
And then I found her. OMG, those squinty eyes – just like I’d remembered. I use to think she squinted to block out the cruelty of the world around her.
It listed her hometown… my hometown. No doubt it was her.
I continued to stare as memories resurfaced. None of them good.
What caused me to pause was that it didn’t look like a whole lot had changed for Mary. Sure, she’d aged like all of us, but what struck me most was how few photos she had of herself – and she had many photos. Only a couple with whom I presumed to be her husband and children.
The few pictures of herself and her family showed a very modest background, which I believed to be her home. Apparently, she never left that style of living. Poverty had followed her through life. But then I thought: she had a husband. So, she was chosen first – maybe for the first time in her life. And the fact she had children, meant she knew what it was like to be loved unconditionally. Regardless of her sad state of her physical surroundings, there was evidence she’d found some happiness.
The rest of her photos? Hundreds – and I mean hundreds, with an emphasis on the plural, were motivational quotes. I fear we may have played a role in turning her into a therapy frequent flier. When someone told her to tell herself a positive affirmation every day, she must have figured that if saying a few inspirational quotes could help fix whatever was wrong, just imagine what a thousand could do.

I stared at her photo and figured this was my opportunity. I whispered an apology from my heart to hers. For every gym class. For every crooked skirt. For every ewww she had to endure. Saying this out loud, I actually had tears, as I realized how much she must have dreaded coming to school. It must have been torture walking into that building. Every. Single. Day.
Someone once told me bullying makes you tough. I thought that was the dumbest, most ignorant comment ever. But maybe – just maybe – those little scars teach us compassion. They remind us what it feels like to be the outsider, so we don’t inflict it on others.
So here’s to you, Mary.
I’m sorry we heckled you when we should’ve been your friends. Nobody called it bullying then, but it was. I’m ashamed.
I’m sorry you were always chosen last and I’m glad to see that someone now chose you first.
I’m sorry I caved to peer pressure and whispered, “Eww,” when I should have whispered, “Hang in there.”
Mary, if you ever want revenge, I’ll volunteer to be picked last for dodgeball. I’ll even wear a crooked skirt in your honor and I’ll stand there like a human target. And when that ball comes flying at me, I promise I won’t dodge. I’ll take the hit, full face, like it’s justice finally served.
Here’s to resilience, compassion, and the reminder that sometimes the people we overlook end up teaching us the biggest lessons.
Cheers, Mary – YOU WIN!


























































